
It’s March 6 in Texas, the date when the The Battle of The Alamo ended with the fort overrun by Santa Ana’s Mexican troops. It was a pivotal moment in the Texas Revolution, which led to the creation of the Republic of Texas, which later joined the US as a state but which has always had an otherness to it compared to the rest of America.
I must have watched at least one or two movies about as I was growing up, possibly via Disney and their stories about Davey Crockett and James Bowie, plus the famous John Wayne movie. I’ve never seen the 2004 version which is apparently quite good, even with Lefty Ron Howard directing – his 1995 movie, Apollo 13 is one of my favourites but I figure there were still guardrails in Hollywood twenty-thirty years ago that prevented Lefties indulging their worst instincts in making stories about America.
Naturally the critics hated it but that’s simply because they hate the story of the Alamo, and how the heroes of the Alamo are valorised in American culture. Billy Bob Thornton is always good value.
The thing is that if Santa Anna hadn’t declared himself basically the Emperor of Mexico, scrapped its constitution, and tried to impose central control, none of this would have happened. The Americans and Mexicans who lived in what is now Texas kept to themselves and intimidated no one, they had no desire to start a revolution and create a nation of their own – until Santa Ana. It’s quite deliberately forgotten by the Lefty critics (“White Supremacy, Slaves, Illegal Immigrants”, etc) that were probably as many Mexicans fighting in the fort as Whites, since they had just as great a desire to live their lives freely as any American.
For two weeks the Mexican Army was stalled in San Antonio at the Alamo, and great losses were inflicted on it by the Alamo defenders, before Santa Anna could resume his pursuit of Sam Houston’s main Texan army. Without the Alamo, he might well have routed Sam Houston’s army and prevented Texas from being created. But instead, Houston defeated Santa Anna’s troops at San Jacinto seven weeks later and captured Santa Ana to boot. Much of western North America was thus liberated from Mexico’s control.
Herewith the famous last letter sent by Col. William Travis from the Alamo eleven days before it fell:
Commandancy of the The Alamo
Bejar, Feby. 24th. 1836To the People of Texas & All Americans in the World-Fellow Citizens & compatriots
I am besieged, by a thousand or more of the Mexicans under Santa Anna – I have sustained a continual Bombardment & cannonade for 24 hours & have not lost a man – The enemy has demanded a surrender at discretion, otherwise, the garrison are to be put to the sword, if the fort is taken – I have answered the demand with a cannon shot, & our flag still waves proudly from the walls – I shall never surrender or retreat. Then, I call on you in the name of Liberty, of patriotism & everything dear to the American character, to come to our aid, with all dispatch – The enemy is receiving reinforcements daily & will no doubt increase to three or four thousand in four or five days. If this call is neglected, I am determined to sustain myself as long as possible & die like a soldier who never forgets what is due to his own honor & that of his country – Victory or Death.
The following is a story told by the last survivor of the Alamo, who was 8 years old when he told his story. He, other children, and the woman trapped in the fort with their men, mostly survived.
In case the X-account fails, here it is copied out:
My father, Gregorio Esparza, belonged to Benavides’ company, in the American army, and I think it was in February, 1836, that the company was ordered to Goliad when my father was ordered back alone to San Antonio, for what I don’t know. When he got here there were rumors that Santa Ana was on the way here, and many residents sent their families away. One of my father’s friends told him that he could have a wagon and team and all necessary provisions for a trip, if he wanted to take his family away. There were six of us besides my father; my mother, whose name was Anita, my eldest sister, myself and three younger brothers, one a baby in arms. I was 8 years old.
My father decided to take the offer and move the family to San Felipe. Everything was ready, when one morning, Mr. W. Smith, who was godfather to my youngest brother, came to our house on North Flores street, just above where the Presbyterian church now is, and told my mother to tell my father when he came in that Santa Ana had come. (Northeast corner of Houston and N. Flores Streets.)
When my father came my mother asked him what he would do. You know the Americans had the Alamo, which had been fortified a few months before by General Cos.
‘Well, I’m going to the fort’ my father said.
‘Well, if pop goes, I am going along, and the whole family too.
It took the whole day to move and an hour before sundown we were inside the fort. Where was a bridge over the river about where Commerce street crosses it, and just as we got to it we could her Santa Anna’s drums beating on Milam Square, and just as we were crossing the ditch going into the fort Santa Anna fired his salute on Milam Square.
There were a few other families who had gone in. A Mrs. Cabury[?] and her sister, a Mrs. Victoriana, and a family of several girls, two of whom I knew afterwards, Mrs. Dickson, Mrs. Juana Melton, a Mexican woman who had married an American, also a woman named Concepcion Losoya and her son, Juan, who was a little older than I.
The first thing I remember after getting inside the fort was seeing Mrs. Melton making circles on the ground with an umbrella. I had seen very few umbrellas. While I was walking around about dark I went near a man named Fuentes who was talking at a distance with a soldier. When the latter got near me he said to Fuentes:
‘Did you know they had cut the water off?’
The fort was built around a square. The present Hugo-Schmeltzer building is part of it. I remember the main entrance was on the south side of the large enclosure. The quarters were not in the church, but on the south side of the fort, on either side of the entrance, and were part of the convent. There was a ditch of running water back of the church and another along the west side of Alamo Plaza. We couldn’t got to the latter ditch as it was under fire and it was the other one that Santa Anna cut off. The next morning after we had gotten in the fort I saw the men drawing water from a well that was in the convent yard. The well was located a little south of the center of the square. I don’t know whether it is there now or not.
On the first night a company of which my father was one went out and captured some prisoners. One of them was a Mexican soldier, and all through the siege, he interpreted the bugle calls on the Mexican side, and in this way the Americans know about the movements of the enemy.
After the first day there was fighting. The Mexicans had a cannon somewhere near where Dwyer avenue now is, and every fifteen minutes they dropped a shot into the fort.
The roof of the Alamo had been taken off and the south side filled up with dirt almost to the roof on that side so that there was a slanting embankment up which the Americans could run and take positions. During the fight I saw numbers who were shot in the head as soon as they exposed themselves from the roof. There were holes made in the walls of the fort and the Americans continually shot from these also. We also had two cannon, one at the main entrance and one at the northwest corner of the fort near the post office. The cannon were seldom fired.
I remember Crockett. He was a tall, slim man, with black whiskers. He was always at the head. The Mexicans called him Don Benito. The Americans said he was Crockett. He would often come to the fire and warm his hands and say a few words to us in the Spanish language. I also remember hearing the names of Travis and Bowie mentioned, but I never saw either of them that I know of.
After the first few days I remember that a messenger came from somewhere with word that help was coming. The Americans celebrated it by beating the drums and playing on the flute. But after about seven days fighting there was an armistice of three days and during this time Don Benito had conferences every day with Santa Anna. Badio, the interpreter, was a close friend of my father, and I heard him tell my father in the quarters that Santa Anna had offered to let the Americans go with their lives if they would surrender, but the Mexicans would be treated as rebels.
During the armistice my father told my mother she had better take the children and go, while she could do so safely. But my mother said:
‘No!, if you’re going to stay, so am I. If they kill one they can kill us all.’
Only one person went out during the armistice, a woman named Trinidad Saucedo.
Don Benito, or Crockett, as the Americans called him, assembled the men on the last day and told them Santa Anna’s terms, but none of them believed that any one who surrendered would get out alive, so they all said as they would have to die any how they would fight it out.
The fighting began again and continued every day, and nearly every night,. One night there was music in the Mexican camp and the Mexican prisoner said it meant that reinforcements had arrived.
We then had another messenger who got through the lines, saying that communication had been cut off and the promised reinforcements could not be sent.
On the last night my father was not out, but he and my mother were sleeping together in headquarters. About 2 o’clock in the morning there was a great shooting and firing at the northwest corner of the fort, and I heard my mother say:
‘Gregorio, the soldiers have jumped the wall. The fight’s begun.’
He got up and picked up his arms and went into the fight. I never saw him again. My uncle told me afterwards that Santa Anna gave him permission to get my father’s body, and that he found it where the thick of the fight had been.
We could hear the Mexican officers shouting to the men to jump over, and the men were fighting so close that we could hear them strike each other. It was so dark that we couldn’t see anything, and the families that were in the quarters just huddled up in the corners. My mother’s children were near her. Finally they began shooting through the dark into the room where we were. A boy who was wrapped in a blanket in one corer was hit and killed. The Mexicans fired into the room for at least fifteen minutes. It was a miracle, but none of us children were touched.
By daybreak the firing had almost stopped, and through the window we could see shadows of men moving around inside the fort. The Mexicans went from room to room looking for an American to kill. While it was still dark a man stepped into the room and pointed his bayonet at my mother’s breast, demanding:
‘Where’s the money the Americans had?’
‘If they had any,’ said my mother, ‘you may look for it.’
Then an officer stepped in and said:
‘What are you doing? The women and children are not to be hurt.’
The officer then told my mother to pick out her own family and get her belongings and the other women were given the same instructions. When it was broad day the Mexicans began to remove the dead. There were so many killed that it took several days to carry them away.
The families, with their baggage, were then sent under guard to the house of Don Ramon Musquiz, which was located where Frank Brothers store now is, on Main Plaza.(Southeast corner of Soledad and Commerce Streets, now a parking lot, 1991). Here we were given coffee and some food, and were told that we would go before the president at 2 o’clock. On our way to the Musquiz house we passed up Commerce street, and it was crowded as far as Presa street with soldiers who did not fire a shot during the battle. Santa Anna had many times more troops than he could use.
At 3 o’clock we went before Santa Anna. His quarters were in a house which stood where L. Wolfson’s store now is.(Middle of Commerce Street, north side, between Main Avenue and Soledad Street). He had a great stack of silver money on a table before him, and a pile of blankets. One by one the women were sent into a side room to make their declaration, and on coming out were given $2 and a blanket. While my mother was waiting her turn Mrs. Melton, who had never recognized my mother as an acquaintance, and who was considered an aristocrat, sent her brother, Juan Losoya, across the room to my mother to ask the favor that nothing be said to the president about her marriage with an American.
My mother told Juan to tell her not to be afraid.
Mrs. Dickson was there, also several other woman. After the president had given my mother her $2 and blanket, he told her she was free to go where she liked. We gathered what belongings we could together and went to our cousin’s place on North Flores street, where we remained several months.
Greetings from the Alamo City. It’s a shame that most of the old fort no longer exists, save for a section of the wall, and of course the iconic chapel that is now at the center of town opposite some incredibly tacky tourist traps.
Four years before the Treaty of Waitangi was signed, Texas was the epitome of wild and untamed people living free, and remains so to this day.
LOL – you decry Russia invading Ukraine to protect her borders but celebrate the USA annexing Texas from Mexico.
What’s that word again, I forget but I think it starts with H.
Your response would be more accurate if I was decrying Russia’s 19th century expansions or the fights over borders occurring across Europe at that time.
Comparing established nations with borders in the 20th-21st centuries to that of the wild west is absurd and something I usually expect from Leftists screaming about de-colonialisation.
You’ll be marching with Te Pati Maori before long.
The USA did not “annex” Texas. Texas was an independent Republic from 1836 to 1848, when it applied to join the United States. The US armed forces did not participate in the Texas Revolution.
Whatever the merit of your argument, there’s no similarity between the two situations.
Actually my friend the situation with Texas almost exactly parallels what happened with respect to Crimea.
Crimea declared independance and then voted to join the Russian Federation.
Texas declared independance from Mexico becoming the Texas Republic then joined the Union,
After that of course Texas joined the Confederacy only to be on the loosing side and is now back in the Union
National boundaries have been changing forever – when it suits the West they celebrate it when it doesn’t they get the vapours and have a hissy fit
I don’t care either way but the South Western States of thhe USA, including California were annexed from Mexico.
You can’t get round that – it happened
You didn’t mention “the Southwestern States” Andrei. You mentioned Texas. I corrected you on the history, and you’re still trying to justify yourself rather than just accept you don’t know the history. And no, it’s not like Crimea at all. Possibly some parallels with how California was founded, but again, you didn’t mention that. If anything, Mexico is Russia in this situation, because it didn’t want the independent Republic Texas to join the US, just as Russia doesn’t want Ukraine to join NATO.
You miss the point EiT
The point being made is that Texas was unambiguously in Mexico but today is part of the US
Blog comments are by their very nature succint and should be, not lending themselves to a detailed account of the Texas Republic.
I remember Francis Fukuyama’s widely derided “End of History” claim made even as NATO was dismembering Yugoslavia to the benefit of the EU
Another quote worth keeping in mind is
History doesn’t repeat it rhymes